- The NCAA's first online harassment study verified more than 5,000 abusive, discriminatory or threatening posts aimed at championship athletes, coaches and officials. Here is what it found, what changed in 2025, the controls that exist, and where Utah athletes can get support.
- This story sits inside Utah's basketball lane and connects to the larger statewide sports picture.
- The story is backed by 9 sources and a visible last-verified date.
November 14, 2026
November 14, 2026
5 min / 1,196 words
9 official links
If you need help right now: call or text 988 for the Suicide and Crisis Lifeline, which is free, confidential and available 24 hours a day, 365 days a year, by call, text or chat. In Utah, calls from a Utah area code reach the Utah Crisis Line, staffed by crisis workers at the Huntsman Mental Health Institute. Utah students can also use SafeUT, a free, confidential service staffed around the clock by licensed counselors, through its app or website. If you are in immediate danger, call 911.
The NCAA's own monitoring counts abuse sent straight to athletes' own profiles. This guide covers what the NCAA has measured, the tools that already exist, and where to take it when it stops being noise.
What the NCAA's first study found
In October 2024 the NCAA released its first study of online harassment in college sports, run with Signify Group's AI-powered Threat Matrix service. The pilot monitored public comments on the social media profiles of 3,164 student-athletes, 489 coaches, 197 game officials, 165 teams and 12 NCAA channels across seven NCAA championships and the College Football Playoff National Championship. The championships were Division I men's and women's basketball, women's volleyball, FCS football, softball, baseball and National Collegiate women's gymnastics.
From roughly 1.3 million posts and comments, the algorithm flagged more than 72,000 messages for human review, and analysts verified more than 5,000 as abusive, discriminatory or threatening. Those were reported to the social media platforms. The study sorted the abuse into 16 categories. The most common was sexual abuse at 18%. Other categories the NCAA reported: sports betting at 12% (more than 740 instances), racist abuse at 10%, homophobic or transphobic abuse at 9% and violent abuse at 6%.
A few findings stand out:
- Women's basketball players received roughly three times as many threats as men's basketball players.
- Betting-related abuse reached 19% in men's basketball and football.
- One student-athlete received more than 1,400 abusive messages in under two weeks.
- The most serious violent content was sent to the NCAA, which shared it with law enforcement.
"Fans have to do better, social media companies have to do more to identify and remove this content," NCAA President Charlie Baker said in the release. Purdue men's basketball coach Matt Painter, quoted in the same release, said abuse of this kind can cause stress, depression and suicidal thoughts.
What changed in 2025
The NCAA published a summary of its 2025 March Madness monitoring on June 10, 2025. Signify watched X, Instagram and TikTok across both Division I basketball tournaments, covering 2,032 players, 346 coaches, 136 teams and 269 game officials and selection committee members. Of more than 1 million posts and comments, 54,096 were flagged and 3,161 were confirmed as abusive or threatening by human analysts.
Confirmed messages were reported to the platforms and, where necessary, to law enforcement, which led to account restrictions and removed posts. Signify ran 103 investigations into accounts posting threatening content and referred 10 matters to law enforcement. Of the abuse found during March Madness, the share aimed directly at student-athletes fell from 42% in 2024 to 15% in 2025. Total abuse in the women's tournament fell about 83%, while total abuse in the men's tournament rose 140%.
The NCAA's own summary says that "experiencing social media abuse may negatively impact student-athletes mental health," and points schools to its Mental Health Best Practices.
The controls that already exist
Instagram, one of the three platforms in the 2025 monitoring, describes its anti-bullying tools on its own community page:
- Hidden Words filters comments and message requests that may be inappropriate or offensive, even when they do not break the rules, and lets you add your own list of words.
- Limits temporarily hides comments and message requests from people who do not follow you, or who only recently followed you.
- Restrict makes a person's comments on your posts visible only to that person, and stops them seeing when you have read their messages or are active.
- Block stops a person seeing your profile, posts or Stories.
- Report sends content that breaks the Community Guidelines to Instagram's team for review.
- Tag and mention controls let you choose whether everyone, only people you follow, or no one can tag or mention you.
Instagram says people are not notified when you report, block or restrict them. Settings like these are easier to put in place on a calm day than in the middle of a pile-on.
Where to take it when it is more than comments
A threat of violence is a safety matter, not a comment-section problem. Tell your athletics department, and if you believe you are in immediate danger, call 911. The NCAA's 2024 release says student-athletes and administrators who want guidance on reducing social media abuse can contact the NCAA's enterprise risk management staff, and that the NCAA expanded its e-learning on handling abusive threats and on sports betting and problem gambling.
The NCAA's mental health resource page lists a course for athletes called "Above the Noise," which covers the forms of online harassment, its health and safety impacts, and strategies to protect well-being. It also lists "Social Media and Mental Health" fact sheets for both student-athletes and staff.
The 2024 release notes that, as of August 1 that year, every Division I school must provide mental health services consistent with the NCAA's Best Practices. Utah programs publish their own. The BYU Athletics counseling page says counseling for eligible student-athletes carries no charge and nothing disclosed is shared with coaches, trainers, professors, parents or the Honor Code without the athlete's permission. Utah State Athletics lists a Director of Mental Wellness for Athletics and confidential services including short-term therapy and crisis consultations. Every Utah school we cover is in our directory of campus mental health resources.
The comments are not the verdict
In the NCAA's 2024 study, 12% of the abuse was directly tied to sports betting, and the NCAA said much of the abuse in other categories was influenced by betting too. Using the filters, reporting what crosses the line and talking to someone on campus are ordinary steps. The Athlete Mind hub collects the rest of this series.
Key facts:
- Crisis lines: 988 Suicide and Crisis Lifeline (call, text or chat, free, confidential, 24/7/365); SafeUT for Utah students (free, confidential, licensed counselors around the clock); 911 for emergencies
- NCAA and Signify pilot study (released October 2024): seven NCAA championships plus the CFP National Championship; about 1.3 million posts, more than 72,000 flagged, more than 5,000 verified as abusive, discriminatory or threatening
- Reported categories: sexual 18% (the most common), sports betting 12%, racist 10%, homophobic or transphobic 9%, violent 6%
- 2025 March Madness (published June 10, 2025): 3,161 confirmed abusive or threatening posts on X, Instagram and TikTok; 103 investigations; 10 referrals to law enforcement; share of March Madness abuse aimed directly at athletes fell from 42% to 15%
- Instagram tools: Hidden Words, Limits, Restrict, Block, Report and tag and mention controls; people are not notified when reported, blocked or restricted
- NCAA resources: "Above the Noise" online harassment course; Social Media and Mental Health fact sheets
- Not medical advice: this article signposts public services and does not give clinical guidance
Get the next story by email
Utah sports reporting, results and athletes to watch. Free to subscribe and easy to unsubscribe.
